Top 7 Over The Counter Skin Tag Removal Products We Recommend

While there’s no need to be overly worried or depressed over the presence of skin tags on your body, as it poses no risk to your health as far as current research on it is concerned, its presence can be a cosmetic nightmare for you.

The presence of skin tags can make you lose your self-confidence. It can make you extremely self-conscious of your body and anxious about how people perceive you. The stigma you have to endure and the kind of lifestyle you’re sometimes forced to live can be demoralizing and painful.

Not everyone will understand that skin tags are merely soft, harmless and noncontagious benign tumors on the skin. Merely trying to explain this fact can be mentally tiring.  The constant stares and unwanted attention directed at you could make you lose your self-esteem and avoid interactions with others.

We don’t want you living through that kind of pain – anxiety, depression and most importantly, having to lose your confidence in yourself. You don’t have to lose interest in what you love doing because of being blackmailed by some harmless benign skin growth called skin tags.

Nah, we don’t want that for you, and that’s why we have taken it upon ourselves to provide you with the best over-the-counter solution (or remedy, whichever suit you. Winks!) to help remove your skin tags.

Skin tags be bygone! No more skin tumors. No more having to shy away from having the fun of your life because of being ashamed of your body.

To this end, we scour lots of OTC skin tags solutions available in the market, pass them through our what-makes-a-skin-tag-remover filters and see what came up. Once relevant results start to pop up, we then apply a second set of filters and picked only the seven (7) that seems to satisfy our requirements.

Now before you go rushing straight down to check out our top 7 picks, wouldn’t you love to know what our sets of filters are, huh?

Yeah yeah! Lets get started.

The moment we started thinking of picking the top 7 products for our readers as the go-to skin tag removal alternative solutions, we ran into some problems and hit a wall. The truth is, there are many over-the-counter skin tags removal products available. Separating the chaff from the seed can be overwhelming and confusing.

So we decided to create a set of filters consisting of the following factors – turnaround time, usage simplicity, risk (side effects), pain, affordability and low risk of scarring.

Turnaround Time

We gave higher preference for products with low turnaround time meaning products that show quick result and help remove skin tags as fast as possible in less than a week or two was good for us.

Usage Simplicity

How easy it is for you to use a skin tumor removal product was also a factor. Something simple to use and easy to understand. We say No to products that requires having a medical training or reading through a 10-page leaflet as a prerequisite to getting a basic understanding of how to use it. It just doesn’t seem enticing, does it?

Side Effects

By risk, we refer to the adverse effects, you might experience during your use of any OTC skin tag removal product. We aimed for products with low side effects. No point in trying to treat a problem and ending up with another one. Going Natural seems to be the best and safest choice.


No Pain, No Gain. Right? Well, the saying is not entirely wrong but nowhere did the proverb mentioned we have to suffer through lots of pain for any sort of gain.  We all have different threshold for pain, and while some of us have the tough-I-can-withstand-the-pain gene, some of us don’t and will chicken out when we perceive any incoming pain.

We want a treatment option that will cause as little pain as possible. A treatment option that people will use. If it doesn’t cause any at all, the better and far up in the list it is for us. There’s no point in buying a product you wouldn’t use. Is there?


Now, this is the real deal breaker. We want a product/treatment option that people can pick up without having their pockets look like a rocket bomb passed through them. We want a product that satisfies most of our factors as mentioned earlier yet cheap enough to open your wallet and go get one. Moreover, there’s no point in shelling out a large sum of your money on OTC products if you can use the same amount to go visit a doctor or dermatologist. It’s a no-brainer.

Low Risk of Scarring

Finally, we want a product that will leave no permanent scar on our body. A product that its use reduces your chances of scarring your skin after treatment.

Well, the moment of truth is finally here. Ta-da! Before we go into detail, here’s a quick summary of our findings:

OTC Product Pricing Info Works Speed Simplicity Safe Value
TagBand Check Price 9.5/10 9/10 9/10 9/10 $$$$$
Apothecary Tea Tree Oil Check Price 8.5/10 5/10 7/10 10/10 $$$$
Haloderm Check Price 7/10 9/10 7/10 5/10 $$$
BuyNaturally Check Price 6.5/10 9/10 7/10 5/10 $$
Kungber Check Price 6/10 10/10 8.5/10 5/10 $$$
Compound W Check Price 6/10 7/10 8/10 7/10 $$$

Our Top Seven (7) Recommended Skin Tag Removal OTC Product

Here are Our Top 7 Skin Tag Removal Products Recommendations and you’re going to love it

TagBand – Skin Tag Removal Kit

The TagBand skin tag remover kit uses a simple method – ligation –to eliminate skin tags from your skin. It works by cutting off the flow of blood to tissues of the skin tags. This result into the skin tags dying and eventually falling off due to lack of blood and oxygen.

The good thing about the TagBand kit is you can expect to start seeing results within the first 7 days of use.


kit is mostly suitable for medium to large skin tags. It’s safe to use on any part of the body and offers little to no pain if done well.

Note: If your skin tags are of the smaller sizes, you might be better off using other recommended product in the list.

Advantages of using the TagBand Skin Tag Removal Kit

It is mostly a set and forget method, which can come in handy if you’re the extremely busy type.

The results are fast and quite permanent. Be rest assured that using the TagBand Kit will help remove skin tags on your body permanently.

Relatively cheaper than a visit to you know who (Huh, your dermatologist)

Risk of irritation is very low compared to other products

Disadvantage of using the TagBand Skin Tag Removal Kit

The TagBand is mostly suited for medium to largely sized skin tags. While there’s a new version for dealing with smaller-sized skin tags – Micro TagBand, you need to ensure that you’re using the right kit to get the best result.  Using the wrong kit might render the treatment ineffective or slow the removal process. .

Reaching some places on your body might prove difficult using the device and might need a second hand to help you with it. For some, asking someone else for help might be a tall order to them which might make the use of this product a no-no.

For those really tiny-sized skin tags, using the band might not work effectively as it might not secure the skin tag firmly.

Apothecary Tea Tree Oil

For those tiny to smaller sized skin tags where the TagBand removal kit can be difficult to use on, the apothecary tea tree oil can be used. This is where the tea tree oil shines. It works by gradually drying off the affected area over the span of some weeks till the skin tags shrink, dries and fall off.

The apothecary tea tree oil is one of our top choices for removing skin tags due to how safe it is to use and its amazing properties – antibacterial, antifungal, antiviral and antiprotozoal properties. This means you not solve your skin tag issue but can use the tea tree oil for other health purposes. Its use is versatile and for the price at which you get it, it’s a lovely catch, and a must have.

Advantages of using Tea Tree Oil

It’s natural. For those of you who prefer taking a natural approach to things, the Apothecary tea tree oil is as the closest you can get. Moreover, we have some individuals who have a “thing” against chemicals and wouldn’t use or touch one with 10 feet handle spoon.

It is highly effective against skin tags. Due to its versatility, you can also use it for other related other related skin issues.

It is affordable and cheaper than a visit to a dermatologist. Also, a bottle of the tea tree oil will last you for a very long time. This makes it one of the cheapest way of treating skin tags.

Disadvantages of Using Tea Tree Oil

It can cause irritation to the skin.

For people suffering from skin dryness, applying tea tree oil can further aggravate the dryness

The result is not as fast as the others in the list.

It is not a set-and-forget procedure as it requires a regular application for maximum result

Pristine Wart & Mole Vanish

Don’t get too worked up on the name, the Pristine Wart & Mole Vanish works wonder on skin tags. It performs its magic using cauterization – the act of coagulating blood and destroying tissue with a hot iron or caustic agent or by freezing.

This product induces a natural cauterization of the affected skin area leading to the removal of your skin tags. Usually, all you need is a one-time application of the cream for 20 mins to perform its wonders. But as you know, they are exceptions to things, and for some largely-sized skin tumors, you might need to reapply the cream for the second time.


The pristine herbal cream containing a blend of natural ingredients – plants of cashew, fig, and lemon – is one of the fastest ways to get quick results as you can start experiencing in as little as less than a week. The kit comes with everything you need to treat benign skin tumors on different areas of the body – antibacterial solution and cotton swabs, applicator sticks and the cream.


Advantages of using the Pristine Wart & Mole Vanish

It is 100% Natural as the ingredients are all derived from plants

Rapid results with a very short timeframe

Less expensive when compared to the cost of a dermatologist or a doctor

Almost a set-and-forget method


Disadvantages of using the Pristine Wart & Mole Vanish

Cauterization causes pain, and the Pristine Wart & Mole Vanish is no different. Though the pain experienced is short lived as it subsides quickly within the next 20 mins or thereabouts.

Causes a temporary scar

Costly than other OTC solutions

Haloderm Advanced Mole and Skin Tag Remover

The Haloderm Advanced Mole and Skin Tag Remover is similar to the Pristine Wart Mole Vanish, being that they are both creams, natural and safe. The cream comes in 5g (17oz) container and can be used for up to 5 medium sized skin tags. You can expect a quick result and get your hopes high using Haloderm as it is blazing fast.

Advantages of using the Haloderm Advanced Mole and Skin Tag Remover

It is easy to use and apply on affected areas with skin tags

It is fast and effective in treating skin tags

Natural and safe for use.

Disadvantages of using the Haloderm Advanced Mole and Skin Tag Remover

Causes a slight burning or stinging sensation to the skin that some might find annoying.

Causes dryness and can lead it to skin irritation.

Unlike the Pristine Wart Vanish Removal, Haloderm does not come with an antibacterial solution. This shoot up the price should you decide to get one yourself which means more money out of wallet.

High risk of scarring especially if you are the I-have-to-pick at those scabs on my body kinda person.

BuyNaturally Skin Tag and Wart Remover Kit

Take the common ingredients found in the Haloderm cream, add Thuja Occidentalis (extracts of the evergreen coniferous tree) plus some extra ingredients and you’ve got a wonderful product sold by BuyNaturally. BuyNaturally is a natural outlet store with various homeopathic treatment options for skin issues.

The BuyNaturally comes in the form of a paste rather than cream. Ha Ah. A change, you might say. The kit comes with everything you need (pre and post) for removing your skin tags. Several cotton swabs, an adhesive bandages, after-healing cream to fasten the healing process, and applicator sticks for applying the paste.

The Pros

A natural product that is safe

Some skin tags can be removed with just one application

You need to purchase any other thing as the kit comes equipped with everything you need to get the job done. Skin tags. Bye-bye.

The Cons

You need a bit of creativity to ensure the paste is administered to the affected area only without getting it on the surrounding skin to avoid stinging or burning your skin.

Getting the paste to stay on the affected area can also be a bit tricky. Trying to work things out could be time-consuming.

Its usage leads to the formation of scab which can cause scarring if you keep picking at it. Leave it alone, please.

Kungber Mole Removal Pen

Noticed a pattern here so far, most of our picks have been products that are primarily used to treat mole or even warts. Let’s just say there’s no need to be worried as these products work fine for skin tags.

Another product in our pick is the Kungber Mole removal pen. It uses cauterization to remove your skin tags. The pen is chargeable as it comes with a rechargeable battery. The pen has six (6) strength levels to choose from depending on the size and nature of your skin tags. It comes with two noodles that are interchangeable and an LCD where you see the battery status and your preferred strength level.

Using this product, all you have to do is switch the device on, wait for the pen to heat up, choose your strength level and sweep around the base of the skin tag. For most skin tags especially the smaller ones, a single procedure is enough. For larger ones and the stubborn type, you might need to repeat the process more than once to get your desired result,

The Pros

Device is rechargeable via USB. Hence, there’s no need to be stuck beside a power outlet when you want to use it. You also do not to change batteries frequently.

A single procedure is all that is needed except for some larger sized skin tags that might require a repeat procedure.

The Cons

Causes a slight pain when used. You might have to purchase a numbing cream and apply to the areas you want to use the pen on to reduce the pain

There’s a risk of scarring especially if not used properly

Not the best product for extremely large-sized skin tags

Compound W Freeze Off Wart Remover

The Compound W Freeze Off Wart Remover works great on skin tags as it does on warts. It uses cryotherapy, which is the use of extremely low temperatures for various medical treatments.

The Compound W Freeze Off Wart Remover uses Dimethyl Ether And Propane as a safe, effective substitute for liquid nitrogen to freeze off your skin tags which cut the flow of blood to the area. As a result, the skin tag dries out after a while, which could take some days and falls off.

First thing you experience as with most products on this list is your skin tags turning black or getting darker in color due to having its blood flow cut off and its cells dying. After that, it’s just a game of waiting a little while for the dead, dried skin to fall off.


The Pros (using the Compound W Freeze Off Wart Remover)

Its usage is cheaper than a visit to a doctor

It is very simple to use. Takes a second to apply and in most cases, especially for smaller sized tags, a single application is enough

Risk of scarring is extremely low. Hallelujah, somebody!


The Cons

You might experience a stinging sensation after applying it to your skin tags.


OTC Product Pricing Info Works Speed Simplicity Safe Value
TagBand Check Price 9.5/10 9/10 9/10 9/10 $$$$$
Apothecary Tea Tree Oil Check Price 8.5/10 5/10 7/10 10/10 $$$$
Haloderm Check Price 7/10 9/10 7/10 5/10 $$$
BuyNaturally Check Price 6.5/10 9/10 7/10 5/10 $$
Kungber Check Price 6/10 10/10 8.5/10 5/10 $$$
Compound W Check Price 6/10 7/10 8/10 7/10 $$$



And that sums up our top 7 recommendations for removing that embarrassing, self-esteem destroyer and a makeup disaster called skin tags. We hope with our recommended solutions, you go find one for yourself and start working on removing those skin tags.

It might not pose a severe risk to your health but it sure as hell ain’t adding any beauty to your body. If anything, it detracts from your beauty.

It is important to note that we’re all different and one product that seems to work for Joe might not be the best product for Alfred or Mary. You need to find out what works for you, considering your current lifestyle and how easy you can use any of the product recommended.

Extra information: On OTC Skin Tag products and Insurance

There’s usually an opposite side to most things in life. Same applies here. While you’re fortunate that skin tags are harmless and do not pose a risk to your health, you can expect the insurance company not to cover its treatment. To them, it’s more of a cosmetic issue than a health issue. Yeah, it’s a pity. But would you rather prefer it poses a serious risk to your health?

Nevertheless, if your skin tags grow really large to the size of a grape or something larger, your insurance might cover it if it affects your quality of life negatively. Also, if a biopsy is done by a doctor and it was discovered you have a much more serious problem like malignant melanoma, this is enough genuine reason to have its treatment covered by insurance.

Leave a Comment